Welcome to Jim Hill Media - Entertainment News : Theme Parks Movies Television

How the makers of Disney's "Moana" almost chickened out

Jim Hill

Jim's musings on the history of and rumors about movies, TV shows, books and theme parks including Disneyland, Walt Disney World. Universal Orlando and Universal Studios Hollywood.

How the makers of Disney's "Moana" almost chickened out

Rate This
  • Comments 2

It's kind of a tradition at Walt Disney Animation Studios that the hero or heroine of each new production has an animal companion. Sometimes they talk (EX: Flounder in "The Little Mermaid") and sometimes they don't (EX: Abu in "Aladdin"). But these furry, feathered or finny friends always provide support - emotional & otherwise - for that film's lead character. More to the point, these animal companions always find a way - even when they can't talk - to comment on the action.

Which brings us to WDAS' soon-to-be-released "Moana." When John Musker & Ron Clements were sussing out the story for this animated epic, they decided that this film's title character should have two animal companions.


Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

First up is Pua, Moana's pet pig. This black & white petite porker is sweet & loyal to his master, the 16-year-old daughter of the Chief of Motunui. Truth be told, Pua is more puppy than pig.

And then there's Heihei. Who's really a dumb cluck. The village idiot in rooster form.

But here's the thing: That wasn't always Heihei's role in "Moana." When Musker & Clements were originally developing their seventh full length animated feature for Disney, they originally had a far different role for this rooster in mind.


(L to R) Ron Clements & John Musker stand in front of an image of
the earlier, smarter version of Heihei at last year's D23 EXPO.
Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

"In the earlier treatments of this story (EDITOR'S NOTE: Minor story spoilers follow ... If you don't want to know anything about "Moana" 's plot prior to seeing this upcoming Walt Disney Pictures release, now would be a good time to bail out of this article), Heihei was actually smart. Kind of an ornery guy but very bright. But he didn't seem quite as funny as we wanted him to be," John recalled during a recent interview. "So we asked 'Moana' 's story team to come up with a funnier take on this rooster character."

Now what made that challenging was - in the original version of this film's story - Heihei is the character that Chief Tui (voiced by Temuera Morrison) assigned to keep a close watch on his daughter. Tui fears that Moana (voiced by Auli'i Cravalho) - given that she is so drawn to the sea - would one day abandon Motunui Island. And given that the Chief wants his daughter to remain on Motunui Island so that someday she could replace him as the leader of their people ... Well, Tui is determined to prevent Moana from venturing beyond the reef that rings their island. Which is why (again, in the earlier version of 'Moana' 's story) the Chief orders Heihei (voiced by Alan Tudyk) to not let his daughter get out of that rooster's sight.

"The directors really wanted to keep Heihei in this movie. But if this rooster was going to be the Chief's watchdog, that meant that Heihei had to be mean & judgy toward Moana. Which then made it really hard for the audience to like this character," said story artist Sunmee Joh.


(L-R) Jared Bush (Screenwriter), Dave Pimentel (Head of Story), David Derrick (Story
Artist) and Sunmee Joh (Story Artist) show story sketches featuring the earlier,
smarter version of Heihei. Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

Heihei was getting such a poor response during "Moana" 's work-in-press screenings that Musker & Clements were giving very serious thought to cutting this character out of the picture. But then that rooster won a reprieve. Largely because this film's screenwriter Jared Bush got a stomach bug and then couldn't come into work for a few days.

"With Jared out of the building, that's when Ron & John told us we had 48 hours to come up with a new take on Heihei. We needed to find a way that this rooster could play an essential role in this movie's plot or his character was going to be cut out of 'Moana,' " Joh continued.

Which is when Sunmee and the other members of the 'Moana' story team began exploring the idea of turning this super-bright, always observant rooster into ... Well, not the sharpest knife in the drawer. As Ron Clements put it, transforming Heihei into " ... the dumbest character in the history of Disney Animation."


Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

And what was the upside of doing that? Well, what if this brain-dead bird stowed away on Moana's raft when - after Motunui is threatened by a terrible darkness -- the chief's daughter ventures far beyond the reef as she searches for that someone or something that could possibly save her people. That would certainly complicate Moana's quest, wouldn't it?

So the "Moana" story team put together a series of drawings which then showed the sort of material that could be mined out of turning Heihei into a moron. And when these drawings were showed to Musker, Clements and John Lasseter (who acts as Chief Creative Officer at both Pixar & Walt Disney Animation Studios), they immediately agreed that this revised version of that rooster was far more amusing than the original. But even so, Heihei's head was still on the chopping block. Largely because his character still wasn't playing a crucial role in "Moana" 's overall plot.

As far as Ron & the two Johns were concerned, it honestly wasn't enough to just make Heihei dumber so that this rooster could then comically complicate Moana's quest. There also had to be a good, solid, story-driven reason to keep this character in the movie.


Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

Which is when the "Moana" story team turned their attention to a midway-through-the-motion-picture action scene that Musker has described as " ... Disney meets 'Fury Road' on the high seas." By this point in the movie, Moana is in possession of the Heart of Te Fiti. Which is this mystical stone that could hold the key to saving Motunui Island (not to mention the rest of the Pacific Ocean) from the approaching darkness.

Unfortunately, there are other characters in "Moana" who also want to get their hands on the Heart of the Sea. These include the Kakamora, pint-sized pirates who wear coconuts for armor.

Anyway ... At this point in the movie, three huge outriggers loaded with Kakamora are bearing down on Moana's diminutive raft. And just as these rascally rogues are about to make off with this mystical object, Heihei swallows the Heart of Te Fiti.


Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

The moment that John Lasseter saw this revised version of the "Moana" storyreel, it's said that he immediately stood up and said "That's it! Heihei is saved! He's back in the movie!"

So how did Sunmee and the rest of the "Moana" story team celebrate the resurrection of this rooster ? In a way that Heihei probably wouldn't have approved of (i.e., Walt Disney Animation Studios treated them all to a chicken dinner).

As for Pua ... Well, this cute little pig is still in the picture. But in spite of some of the official "Moana" images that you may have previously seen floating around the Web  ...


Copyright Disney Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved

... Pua didn't actually join his mistress on her voyage. What happened there? That's a behind-the-scenes story that I'll save for another time. For now (and for Heihei's sake), let's just be happy that the makers of Disney's "Moana" didn't wind up chickening out.

This article was originally published by the Huffington Post back on Thursday, September 8, 2016

Blog - Post Feedback Form
Your comment has been posted.   Close
Thank you, your comment requires moderation so it may take a while to appear.   Close
Leave a Comment
  • * Please enter your name
  • * Please enter a comment
  • Post
  • "The directors really wanted to keep Heihei in this movie. But if this rooster was going to be the Chief's watchdog, that meant that Heihei had to be mean & judgy toward Moana. Which then made it really hard for the audience to like this character," - That was never a problem with Sebastian who basically had the same role in Mermaid. Is it not much more likely they just decided it was far too similar to Mermaid's characters?

  • Great read, but I'd say it's a got a few moderate spoilers in it. Could you preface this with a minor spoiler tag to warn people?

Page 1 of 1 (2 items)